Updated November 2026

Craftsman tiller replacement tines are the most common repair for a worn or broken tiller, and choosing the wrong set wastes time. This guide compares six sets based on the criteria that matter most: model fit, tine count, left- and right-hand balance, included hardware and the clarity of the part numbers in each listing. Use it to match the right set to your tiller before you order.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 18 Tiller Tines Fits Craftsman 4459J 4460J 6554J 6555JTOP CHOICEBest overall8 Tiller Tines Fits Craftsman 4459J 4460J 6554J 6555JView on Amazon
  2. 2Hicarer 12 Pcs Replacement Tiller TinesTOP CHOICEBest for a 12-tine setHicarer 12 Pcs Replacement Tiller TinesView on Amazon
  3. 3For 16 Tine Set Fits For MTD Craftsman Tiller Tines With HardwareTOP CHOICEBest for a 16-tine rebuildFor 16 Tine Set Fits For MTD Craftsman Tiller Tines With HardwareView on Amazon
  4. 4Fits Troy-Bilt Lh Outer Tine AssemblyBest for a single outer tineFits Troy-Bilt Lh Outer Tine AssemblyView on Amazon
  5. 5Set of Twenty-Four Right/Left Aftermarket Tiller TinesBest for bulk replacementSet of Twenty-Four Right/Left Aftermarket Tiller TinesView on Amazon
  6. 6Set of 8 Replacement Roto Tiller TinesBest for a small setSet of 8 Replacement Roto Tiller TinesView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Product Best for Key feature
8 Tiller Tines Fits Craftsman 4459J 4460J 6554J 6555J Matching an 8-tine Craftsman tiller Four left, four right, hardware included
Hicarer 12 Pcs Replacement Tiller Tines A 12-tine replacement set Six left, six right, 36 screws and nuts
For 16 Tine Set Fits For MTD Craftsman Tiller Tines With Hardware Full 16-tine rebuild Cross-brand MTD and Craftsman fit
Troy-Bilt Lh Outer Tine Assembly Replacing one damaged outer tine Left-hand outer tine assembly
Set of Twenty-Four Aftermarket Tiller Tines Restocking or replacing many tines Twenty-four tines, right and left
Set of 8 Replacement Roto Tiller Tines A small, targeted replacement Eight tines with multiple part numbers

8 Tiller Tines Fits Craftsman 4459J 4460J 6554J 6555J

Four left-hand and four right-hand tines with hardware. Replaces 4459J, 4460J, 6554J and 6555J on 8-tine tillers. 8 Tiller Tines Fits Craftsman 4459J 4460J 6554J 6555J

Four left-hand and four right-hand tines with hardware. Replaces 4459J, 4460J, 6554J and 6555J on 8-tine tillers. 8 Tiller Tines Fits Craftsman 4459J 4460J 6554J 6555J

View on Amazon

Best for: Matching an 8-tine Craftsman tiller

This set suits owners who want a direct replacement for the listed Craftsman part numbers and a balanced left and right set.

Pros:

  • Four left-hand and four right-hand tines in one set
  • Hardware included with the tines

Cons:

  • Only fits 8-tine models with the listed part numbers

View on Amazon

Hicarer 12 Pcs Replacement Tiller Tines

Hicarer 12 Pcs Replacement Tiller Tines, Includes 6 Left-Handed Cultivator Tines 6 Right-Handed Rotavator, with 36 Screws and Nuts, 1.25" Wide x 11" Long, Tiller Blade Accessories

Hicarer 12 Pcs Replacement Tiller Tines, Includes 6 Left-Handed Cultivator Tines 6 Right-Handed Rotavator, with 36 Screws and Nuts, 1.25" Wide x 11" Long, Tiller Blade Accessories

View on Amazon

Best for: A 12-tine replacement set

This set fits owners replacing a larger number of worn tines who want the hardware in the same box.

Pros:

  • Six left-handed and six right-handed tines
  • 36 screws and nuts included

Cons:

  • Listing does not tie every tine to a single Craftsman model number

View on Amazon

For 16 Tine Set Fits For MTD Craftsman Tiller Tines With Hardware

For 16 Tine Set Fits For MTD Fits for Sears Fits For Craftsman Tiller Tines With Hardware 108802, for craftsman garden tiller tines, for craftsman 917294260 tiller tine, for craftsman tiller tines

For 16 Tine Set Fits For MTD Fits for Sears Fits For Craftsman Tiller Tines With Hardware 108802, for craftsman garden tiller tines, for craftsman 917294260 tiller tine, for craftsman tiller tines

View on Amazon

Best for: Full 16-tine rebuild

This set is aimed at owners rebuilding the entire tine assembly on a 16-tine machine or a tiller with mixed MTD and Craftsman parts.

Pros:

  • Covers a full 16-tine set with hardware
  • Lists several Craftsman and MTD part references

Cons:

  • Cross-brand listing means you should confirm your part number before ordering

View on Amazon

Fits Troy-Bilt Lh Outer Tine Assembly

Fits Troy-Bilt Yard-Machines Ranger Colt Boss World Roto Red RB FT 500 330 300 250 340 390 240 342 332 220 MTD Replacement Part Lh Outer Tine Assembly

Fits Troy-Bilt Yard-Machines Ranger Colt Boss World Roto Red RB FT 500 330 300 250 340 390 240 342 332 220 MTD Replacement Part Lh Outer Tine Assembly

View on Amazon

Best for: Replacing one damaged outer tine

This is a single left-hand outer tine assembly, useful when only one tine has bent or broken and the rest of the set is in good shape.

Pros:

  • Lets you replace one tine without buying a full set
  • Lists a long run of compatible Troy-Bilt and MTD models

Cons:

  • Left-hand only, so you need a matching right-hand part

View on Amazon

Set of Twenty-Four Right/Left Aftermarket Tiller Tines

Set of Twenty-Four 12 Each Right/Left Aftermarket Tiller Tines Compatible/Replacement for Tarter Gate 100 & 200 Series Tiller Tine 9000012/9000013

Set of Twenty-Four 12 Each Right/Left Aftermarket Tiller Tines Compatible/Replacement for Tarter Gate 100 & 200 Series Tiller Tine 9000012/9000013

View on Amazon

Best for: Bulk replacement

This set suits owners servicing several tillers or replacing most of the tines on a heavily used machine.

Pros:

  • Twenty-four tines in right and left pairs
  • Good value when many tines wear at once

Cons:

  • Aftermarket part, so fit depends on matching the listed part numbers

View on Amazon

Set of 8 Replacement Roto Tiller Tines

Set of 8 Replacement Roto Tiller Tines 1901118A 1901118 742-0105 742-0106 (8)

Set of 8 Replacement Roto Tiller Tines 1901118A 1901118 742-0105 742-0106 (8)

View on Amazon

Best for: A small, targeted replacement

This eight-tine set fits owners who want a compact replacement without ordering a large kit.

Pros:

  • Eight tines lists several part numbers for cross-checking
  • Manageable quantity for a single tiller

Cons:

  • Not all listed numbers are Craftsman-specific, so check your model first

View on Amazon

Lauren Holland

About Lauren Holland

Lauren Holland is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our garden hand tools & equipment guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.